NFL Preseason Disappointments: Key Players Underperform
The NFL preseason is nearing its end, providing coaches a chance to assess their teams before the official start of the 2026 season. This period allows for evaluation of positional battles and roster strengths, although many star players typically do not participate to avoid injury.
Among the players who did not capitalize on their opportunities is Fernando Mendoza, the first overall draft pick, who completed only 55.6% of his passes with one touchdown and two interceptions. Tua Tagovailoa, signed by Atlanta, also struggled, showing a conservative playing style that resulted in a low average depth of target. Darius Slayton of the Giants faced scrutiny for his lack of targets in a crucial preseason game, raising questions about his future with the team.
Other notable disappointments include rookie Makai Lemon, who had a lackluster performance after recovering from injury, and Kaleb Johnson, who failed to secure a role in Pittsburgh's backfield. Trevor Etienne's preseason was cut short due to injury, leaving uncertainty about his contributions this season. As the preseason wraps up, these players will need to improve to secure their spots on the final rosters.
